The Giving Tree redux. A new ending with new pictures. The man sits on the stump with the caption, "And the tree was happy." But was it really?
The Giving Tree sequel (redux). Four new pages with new pictures added to "The Giving Tree" to make it more inspiring and eco-friendly. Illustrated and type set in the style of the original. Pictured here are pages 1-2 of 4.

The Giving Tree Sequel

How It Should Have Ended (HISHE)

The Giving Tree sequel (redux). The final pages revised. The old man reaches into his pocket and discover long lost seeds. A seed grows into a new tree.
What if instead of the tree being reduced to a stump the cycle of life continues with a lesson conveyed to the next generation, both a grandson and an apple sapling?

Have you ever read the classic children’s story “The Giving Tree” by Shel Silverstein? I’ve always been disturbed that the tree sacrifices itself to a greedy old man — so I rewrote the ending and drew new pictures. Call it: The Giving Tree Sequel or The Giving Tree Redux. The last 4 pages pictured here are my new ending. I also matched the layout, font and typesetting exactly to the original book.

Last seen the old man is sitting on the stump of the tree looking forlorn. The tree is happy to see his old friend and offer him a place to sit; that is all the tree has left to give. But, presumably, the man is unhappier than ever after having taken the tree’s friendship for granted and realizing he has killed the tree with his greed. Giving credit to the original author, Shel Silverstein, perhaps the young readers are meant to learn to stop being so greedy and destructive, yet I wonder why the tree is still happy? And the man seems little changed by his actions, so there is not much character growth there.

Let me know how you think the Giving Tree should have ended in the comments below.

Share this story:

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on email
Email
  • Avatar Ben says:

    No, No, No! It’s a story about death and things coming to an end.

  • Avatar Pam says:

    I like your ending better

  • Avatar Laura says:

    I’ve returned to this book for almost 50 years .. from a young child to an older woman. I still treasure it and your ending encapsulates the “redemption” theme In many ways. However, the Giving Tree must somehow learn not to give so much of herself that she has nothing left for her. No martyrdom. She needs Boundaries please.

    • Thanks for your comment. You added a whole new level of meaning for me. Of course, the tree has a lesson to be learned, too. Maybe the book needs yet another page? Or is it best left to the reader’s imagination.

  • More stories like this one:

    Boarding Pass for NASA's Mars 2020 mission with the planet Mars in the background

    Send your name to Mars

    Join Scott on his mission to Mars. Well… really it is just his name etched in silicon that will be going on NASA’s 2020 Mars Rover, but anyone can join.

    A DVD of the Bollywood movie “Chura Liyaa Hai Tumne."

    My Bollywood debut as a backup dancer

    My debut video as a backup dancer in a Bollywood blockbuster movie. This is the catchy song “Mohabbat Hai Mirchi” from the movie “Chura Liyaa Hai Tumne.”

    The Hero's Journey

    What is an adventure?

    Words like adventure, hero and epic have become cliches that have lost their meaning. So unfortunately we can’t say: “I’m a a hero going on an epic adventure,” and be meaningful. So, what exactly is an adventure? And how do we make every day an adventure?

    If you enjoyed this story, please make a small donation to help us with our cost and keep Scott caffeinated. Or go a little bigger, to fund a School Visit, the Make-A-Book Project or Book Donations. Thanks to everyone that has helped us make dreams come true for the past 20 years!

    >

    Looks like your enjoying our site

    Join our bi-Annual Newsletter
    to get premium content

    Get the
    latest news

    Sign up for our biannual newsletter to get updates, discounts and premium content.